In the summer of 2017, 53-year-old Jeff Murphy set off on a hike in Yellowstone National Park. Unlike most hikers, Murphy wasn’t just seeking adventure—he was hunting for a fortune. His quest for Forrest Fenn’s hidden treasure, a chest filled with gold and jewels worth up to $5 million, ended in tragedy.
Murphy wasn’t the first to die searching for Fenn’s fabled riches, nor was he the last. At least five treasure hunters lost their lives chasing the fortune, yet thousands continued their pursuit. The legend of Fenn’s treasure turned into one of the most infamous modern-day treasure hunts, sparking fascination, controversy, and deadly consequences.
How the Forrest Fenn Treasure Hunt Began
Forrest Fenn, a decorated Vietnam War veteran and wealthy art dealer, lived a life fit for an adventure novel. After surviving 328 combat missions, he turned his passion for artifacts into a multi-million-dollar business, selling rare collectibles to clients like Steven Spielberg and Jacqueline Onassis.
In 1988, a cancer diagnosis forced Fenn to confront his legacy. His response? A bold plan to hide a Romanesque treasure chest filled with gold nuggets, rare coins, and precious gems somewhere in the Rocky Mountains, intending to die beside it. However, after surviving cancer, he proceeded with the hunt anyway. In 2010, he published The Thrill of the Chase, a memoir containing a 24-line poem with nine cryptic clues leading to the treasure’s location.
Cracking the Nine Clues
The poem’s first clue, “Begin it where warm waters halt,” ignited endless speculation. Some believed it pointed to hot springs in the Rockies, while others thought it described the confluence of warm and cold waters in trout-filled rivers. Treasure hunters dissected every word, flooding online forums and Reddit threads with theories, yet the true location remained a mystery.
Other clues, like “Put in below the home of Brown” and “If you’ve been wise and found the blaze,” only deepened the mystery. Some searchers kept their discoveries secret, fearing rivals would steal their solutions. Many wandered into treacherous wilderness, risking their lives in pursuit of fortune.
The Deadly Toll of the Treasure Hunt
Fenn’s treasure lured more than 300,000 seekers into the Rockies, and some never returned. In 2017, 52-year-old Paris Wallace disappeared near the Rio Grande while searching for the chest. Days later, authorities found his body.
As the death toll climbed, law enforcement grew alarmed. Montana’s Gallatin County Sheriff’s Office issued warnings about the hunt’s dangers, citing unforgiving terrain, wild animals, and the lack of cellphone service. In June 2019, they posted a plea on Facebook, urging treasure hunters to reconsider before endangering their own lives—and those of rescuers.
Despite these tragedies, Fenn refused to call off the search. Instead, he provided additional clues and stressed the importance of safety. He reminded hunters that he was 80 years old when he hid the chest, meaning the location had to be accessible to a man of his age. Still, the search continued, driven by hope, obsession, and the dream of striking it rich.
The Treasure Is Found—Or Was It?
In June 2020, Fenn shocked the world with an announcement: someone had found the treasure. A man from the East Coast had uncovered the chest and provided photographic proof. However, Fenn refused to reveal the winner’s identity or the treasure’s exact location, sparking controversy.
Many treasure hunters remained skeptical. Chicago attorney Barbara Andersen claimed someone had stolen her solution and used it to find the chest. She filed an injunction to prevent the treasure from being sold. Meanwhile, Colorado resident David Harold Hanson sued Fenn for $1.5 million, alleging that misleading clues led him astray.
Others questioned whether the treasure ever existed at all. Some believed the entire hunt was an elaborate ruse. “In 2020, he said the treasure was found but won’t share any details, so no one can question his narrative,” one skeptic noted.
Forrest Fenn passed away in September 2020 at the age of 90, taking many of the hunt’s secrets with him. Whether the treasure was real or a masterful illusion, its impact remains undeniable. It captivated the world, inspired thousands, and, tragically, claimed several lives.
Don’t forget to tune in…
If you’ve enjoyed this article, there are also articles on a 14th-century castle where archaeologists recently unearth 103 exquisite silver artifacts—long thought lost to time, likely hidden away from Nazi looters.
Or consider the enduring mystery of Oak Island, where for over two centuries, treasure hunters have braved perilous conditions in search of rumored pirate gold or even Shakespeare’s missing manuscripts. The island, steeped in legend and lore, continues to draw adventurers, fueled by the hope of unearthing its secrets.
You can now tune in to the full audio version of this week’s blog via the Bell’s Books and Blog Podcast here Bells Books Blog Podcast, or it is now available on Amazon Music/Audible, Apple Podcasts, Castbox, Deezer, iHeart Radio, JioSaavn, Podcast Addict, Podchaser, Spotify, and Spreaker.
Thank you for joining me in this week’s exploration of historical hidden treasure! The past can’t keep her secrets for long; it whispers of stories just waiting to be uncovered.
I encourage you to sign up for my weekly blog. When you do so you will get a free copy of Yesteryear’s Ruin, the prequel to my new Case 47 series.
Until next time, keep your curiosity alive and your imagination ignited— and as always, keep the past alive!
“Yesteryear’s Ruin” captures the essence of human resilience in the face of unimaginable loss. Through a narrative that weaves together love, despair, and the quest for redemption, this historical psychological thriller invites readers into a world where the past is not merely a memory, but a realm that may hold the key to our deepest desires and darkest fears.